| # | name, age | city | time | poll: your holiday wish? |
| 1. | Mark Stickley, 38 | Winchester, VA | 16:30 | a pay raise |
| 2. | Jared Prunty, 18 | Winchester, VA | 17:21 | a walrus that doesn't smell bad |
| 3. | Chris Northrup, 37 | Winchester, VA | 18:21 | n/a |
| 4. | Dustin Sweeney, 17 | Berryville, VA | 18:35 | a new Grandma |
| 5. | Neal Riemenschneider, 46 | Winchester, VA | 19:01 | Flexible Flyer |
| 6. | Ryan Bayne, 20 | Winchester, VA | 19:14 | a 20 ft. candy cane |
| 7. | Michael Wilcox, 26 | Washington, VA | 19:49 | a roller girl |
| 8. | Zach Frye, 14 | Winchester, VA | 19:59 | nothing; I have it all |
| 9. | Kennon Yeck, 39 | Mt. Jackson, VA | 20:22 | multiple responses |
| 10. | Erjan Akkus, 23 | Stephens City, VA | 20:44 | a sub-15 minute 5K |
| 11. | Jon Campbell, 48 | Boyce, VA | 20:47 | tennis shorts |
| 12. | Terry Leckie, 37 | Front Royal, VA | 20:58 | n/a |
| 13. | Richard Updike, 34 | Front Royal, VA | 20:59 | a pony |
| 14. | Charles Bowles, 18 | Boyce, VA | 21:11 | a cat that doesn't lick the butter |
| 15. | Ruth Riemenschneider, 43 | Winchester, VA | 21:18 | a REAL man |
| 16. | Joel McKenzie, 39 | Stephens City, VA | 21:22 | a recount in Florida |
| 17. | Randy Wingfield, 55 | Winchester, VA | 21:28 | n/a |
| 18. | Rick Kerby, 40 | Berryville, VA | 21:37 | to hear Charles Bowles say more than ten words in a row |
| 19. | William Frye, 41 | Winchester, VA | 21:37 | new running shoes |
| 20. | Denny Myers, 46 | Stephens City, VA | 21:59 | new running shoes |
| 21. | Michelle VanHorn, 19 | Harpers Ferry, WV | 22:04 | college paid for |
| 22. | Keith Kreuz, 39 | Hedgesville, WV | 22:19 | world peace |
| 23. | John Rice, 35 | Martinsburg, WV | 22:24 | nothing; I have it all |
| 24. | Emily Harrison, 14 | Front Royal, VA | 22:37 | nothing; I have it all |
| 25. | Christina Moore, 13 | Front Royal, VA | 22:51 | a recount in Florida |
| 26. | Mike Allen, 44 | Winchester, VA | 22:55 | other (not specified) |
| 27. | Rachel Eisenfeld, 14 | Winchester, VA | 23:11 | new running shoes |
| 28. | Bill Daniels, 49 | Berryville, VA | 23:18 | nothing; I have it all |
| 29. | Laurie Murphy, 12 | Louisa, VA | 23:30 | a pony |
| 30. | Leslie Lawson, 18 | Charles Town, WV | 23:41 | a new sports car (Viper RT/10) |
| 31. | Jonathan Whitehead, 24 | Winchester, VA | 23:59 | a recount in Florida |
| 32. | Vicky Krossman, 31 | Winchester, VA | 24:02 | world peace |
| 33. | Tracy Rice, 30 | Martinsburg, WV | 24:22 | nothing; I have it all |
| 34. | Pete Martin, 62 | Winchester, VA | 24:24 | nothing; I have it all |
| 35. | Paul Grosz, 52 | Stephens City, VA | 24:28 | a pay raise |
| 36. | Mark Belanger, 39 | Front Royal, VA | 25:08 | a new PC |
| 37. | Nancy Specht, 48 | Bunker Hill, WV | 25:21 | a pay raise (she's a teacher) |
| 38. | Herb Sturm, 50 | Stephens City, VA | 25:37 | nothing; I have it all |
| 39. | M. Triantafillou, 41 | Winchester, VA | 25:51 | nothing; I have it all |
| 40. | Cheryl Harrison, 36 | Front Royal, VA | 26:00 | nothing; I have it all |
| 41. | Judy Masi, 41 | Berryville, VA | 26:13 | new running shoes |
| 42. | Lauren Allen, 16 | Winchester, VA | 26:41 | new running shoes |
| 43. | Lorie Weimar, 39 | Warrenton, VA | 26:51 | new running shoes |
| 44. | Melissa Moore, 13 | Front Royal, VA | 27:20 | new running shoes |
| 45. | Amy Dzien, 26 | Stephens City, VA | 27:20 | a pay raise |
| 46. | Anna Lawrence, 14 | Berryville, VA | 27:27 | a new sports car |
| 47. | Lynne Lawrence, 41 | Berryville, VA | 27:35 | my two front teeth |
| 48. | Connie Miller-Mathews, 29 | Leesburg, VA | 27:48 | n/a |
| 49. | Austin Cote, 11 | Winchester, VA | 28:37 | new running shoes |
| 50. | Anna Cote, 12 | Winchester, VA | 28:38 | a scooter |
| 51. | Jen Peachey, 26 | Boyce, VA | 29:28 | nothing; I have it all |
| 52. | Reynold Orchard*, 56 | Front Royal, VA | 29:39 | n/a |
| 53. | Kim Weisgerber-Craig, 34 | Stephens City, VA | 29:44 | nothing; I have it all |
| 54. | Terry Bursey, 51 | Manassas, VA | 29:52 | new running shoes |
| 55. | Beth Keeley, 24 | Winchester, VA | 30:25 | a pony |
| 56. | Polly Barks, 11 | Berryville, VA | 30:47 | a pony |
| 57. | Kim Salata, 32 | Winchester, VA | 31:00 | world peace |
| 58. | Eldon Winston, 65 | Martinsburg, WV | 31:15 | n/a |
| 59. | Lynn Miller, 39 | Winchester, VA | 31:45 | multiple responses |
| 60. | Jeannette Harden, 31 | Stephens City, VA | 32:49 | new running shoes |
| 61. | Irene Barrett, 33 | Hamilton, VA | 33:40 | world peace |
| 62. | Tom Sullivan, 59 | Winchester, VA | 35:46 | n/a |
| 63. | Beth Heick, 37 | Winchester, VA | 36:07 | world peace (if not available, then running shoes) |
| 64. | Laura Daniels, 12 | Berryville, VA | 38:16 | nothing; I have it all |
| 65. | Molly McMillen, 13 | White Post, VA | 38:26 | nothing; I have it all |
| 66. | Gabby Vaughn, 41 | Cross Junction, VA | 39:03 | multiple responses |
| 67. | Nancy Gauthier, 38 | Cross Junction, VA | 39:03 | fast shoes! |
| 68. | Sheri Kreuz, 40 | Hedgesville, WV | 42:20 | nothing; I have it all |
| 69. | Audrey Lawrence, 11 | Berryville, VA | 42:33 | n/a |
| 70. | Steven Dobbin, 41 | Winchester, VA | 46:18 | n/a |
| 71. | Celeste Heath, 38 | Berryville, VA | 51:05 | new ballet shoes |
| 72. | Ed Barks, 46 | Berryville, VA | 51:05 | Karsten to cut his hair |
| 73. | Jessie Daniels, 9 | Berryville, VA | 51:48 | n/a |
| 74. | Susan Daniels, 49 | Berryville, VA | 51:48 | n/a |
| 75. | Bob Atkins**, 75 | Winchester, VA | 57:10 | n/a |